McCrea's Candies

McCrea's packs orders by hand and ships them Monday to Friday by UPS, usually within 2 to 3 business days of the order; its policy page allows 3 to 5. In summer it does not ship on Fridays. Shipping costs $7 on orders of $29.90 and under and $8 to $9 on larger orders, depending on location, and orders over $75 ship free. If you send gifts to several addresses during a free-shipping promotion, each address has to meet the threshold after discounts.

McCrea's ships only to US addresses, so there is no delivery to Canada, Australia or the UK.

The brand publishes no holiday order-by dates and no warm-weather packing details, so order Christmas gifts by early December and email [email protected] if timing matters.

Because every product is food, McCrea's does not accept returns, and there is no warranty. If an order arrives damaged or something else goes wrong, email the team with the details and it promises to do its best to make it right.

McCrea's makes about 16 caramel flavors. The staples include Black Lava Sea Salt, its 2016 Good Food Award winner, Cape Cod Sea Salt, Classic Vanilla, Deep Chocolate, Tapped Maple with New England maple syrup and Single Malt Scotch, with Rosemary Truffle Sea Salt, Ginger Fusion and Dark Roasted Mocha in the nine-flavor Flavor Family Box. Seasonal flavors this year include Chocolate Peppermint, Chocolate Orange and Cold Brew Coffee.

Single flavors come as 1.4oz pillow boxes of about five pieces ($5.95) or 5.5oz tubes of about 19 pieces ($22.95). Gift lines include flavor trio gable boxes of 15 caramels for occasions such as birthdays and thank-yous ($14.95), the 4-Pillow Gift Sampler ($24.95), the Tall Gift Box of three tubes ($69.95) and the Party Box with about 20 pieces of each of four flavors ($79.95). The holiday range adds two advent calendars and the Magic & Merriment Collection.

For a first taste, the Flavor Family Box gives four pieces of nine flavors for $35.95 and works as a tasting flight. For a small thank-you or a stocking stuffer, a $14.95 gable box trio or a $5.95 pillow box keeps the cost down.

For a December countdown, the two advent calendars hold 24 caramels in eight flavors for $39.95 each. For an office or a party, the Party Box brings about 80 pieces, and a case of six pillow boxes at $29.75 splits easily into individual gifts.

Check allergies before you send: every caramel contains milk, and the kitchen also processes tree nuts and sesame. Single Malt Scotch lists single malt Scotch among its ingredients, so pick another flavor for anyone avoiding alcohol.

Prices on mccreascandies.com run from $5.95 for a pillow box to $79.95 for the Party Box, and gift cards come in $25, $50, $75 and $100. A case of six pillow boxes costs $29.75, less than buying six singly at $5.95, and orders over $75 ship free within the US.

The store has a Sale section, and in early November 2026 the Deep Chocolate tube was marked at $15.95 against its usual $22.95. Sale stock changes often, so check before you buy.

We do not list coupon codes we have not tested. To catch a lower price before Black Friday or the holidays, set a price alert on In-Right's Watchlist at /watchlist/.